The battle over who is mayor is not over yet

Former mayor Adam Alharbi has called for the Wayne County Board of Canvassers to recount 37 ballots that have been at the center of a year-long dispute over who won last year’s November mayoral election. File photo

Update: The recount of the 37 ballots on Friday, Nov. 20, did not change the election results. Mayor Muhith Mahmood remains in the position of mayor.
By Charles Sercombe
Former mayor Adam Alharbi isn’t giving up the fight to reclaim his office.
He has asked for a recount of 37 ballots that have been at the center of a dispute over who won the mayoral seat in last year’s November election.
His challenger in that election, Muhith Mahmood, successfully won his fight to have those ballots included in the results. The 37 ballots in question were found in the city clerk’s office a day after the November 2025 election.
Alharbi insisted that they should not be counted since they had lost their “chain of custody,” while Mahmood argued that not counting the ballots would disenfranchise those voters.
The state court of appeals eventually sided with Mahmood, and ordered the Wayne County Board of Canvassers to count those votes.
When the dust had cleared, Mahmood ended up winning the mayoral election by 12 votes.
Alharbi had recently requested a recount of the entire November 2025 election, but the Wayne County Board of Canvassers rejected that request.
A recount had already taken place for that election without including the 37 uncounted ballots, and it did nothing to change who had won the position of mayor.
That recount request was made by Mahmood right after the November 2025 election. Alharbi had been determined the winner by 11 votes.
In most election ballot recounts, it is rare for there to end up being any significant changes in the final tally.
At press time, the recount had not yet begun.
That’s not all Alharbi is doing to reclaim the title of mayor.
He is also appealing a Wayne County Circuit Court decision that rejected his argument that Mahmood is not actually a resident of Hamtramck, and instead lives in Troy with this wife and family.
The judge in that case said the evidence Alharbi submitted over the residency issue was “scant, at best.”
But he is still persisting in the matter.
“I want Hamtramck residents to have clear answers about how those ballots were handled and counted,” Alharbi said, on his Facebook page.
And if all that fails, Alharbi said there is an “alternative path,” hinting he will call for the community to support a recall election against Mahmood.
“If the court system fails to enforce justice, then there’s an alternative path our residents will take to resolve this issue,” he said.
Alharbi told The Review:
“That ‘alternative path’ is simply letting the voters weigh in through a recall election. People in our community are frustrated and want to see accountability. If the courts don’t resolve the issue, residents have every legal right to organize, gather signatures, and let the voters decide.”
In Michigan, recalls can’t take place in the first or last six months of an elected official’s term. Mahmood has only been in office for a little over a week.
There is also another hurdle: getting approval for the language of a recall petition has become tougher.
Most recall petitions are rejected, based on the lack of clarity in the language of the proposed ballot question.
So far, Hamtramck taxpayers are picking up the legal tab for Alharbi’s fight to regain the job of mayor. That bill now stands at about $200,000. A bare majority of city councilmembers — Abu Musa, Nayeem Choudhury and Muhtasin Sadman — approved Alharbi’s request for the city to pay his legal fees.
Reaction to Alharbi’s call for voters to remove Mahmood ranged from support for his position to appeals for him to drop the matter and move on.
“Brother Adam, sometimes the real battle is not in the courts or ballot boxes, but in our ability to bring people together and unite hearts,” said Abo Adam, on social media.
“That is why I hope you do not exhaust all your energy and time in appeals, with all our respect for the judiciary and your right to seek justice. Look to the future, prepare now for the next stage, and make your goal bringing together the sons of the community instead of increasing the distances between them.”
But others encouraged Alharbi to continue the fight.
“Good luck; God willing, you are on the right path, and this is a step that serves the community and fights corruption if it exists,” said Farooq Ali.
Posted Nov. 20, 2026

Comments (0)

There are no comments on this article.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.